Email newsletters are experiencing a powerful resurgence. Readers want to curate their inbox experience, cutting through the noise of social media and seeking trusted voices delivering insights directly to them. As a writer, creator, or business owner, harnessing the power of a newsletter is a brilliant way to form authentic connections with your audience.

But, which platform is best for launching your newsletter empire? Two contenders I have tried personally stand out for their simplicity yet powerful features: Substack and beehiiv. Let's break down the benefits of each to help you make an informed decision.

Substack: Simplicity Personified

Substack burst onto the scene with a laser focus on ease of use. If you crave a minimalist interface and the primary goal is to write and send newsletters, Substack could be a great option. Its strengths include:

• No-fuss setup: Get started in a matter of minutes. There are very few decisions to make when setting up your publication.

• Clean writing interface: The writing experience is free of distractions, letting you focus on your words.

• Free to start: Substack allows for unlimited subscribers with its free plan, making it ideal for dipping your toes into newsletter creation without financial commitment.

• Discoverability: Substack has a built-in network where readers can find new publications, potentially increasing the organic reach of your newsletter.

Limitations of Substack

Substack's simplicity also means some limitations that might hold you back as your newsletter grows:

• 10% revenue share: Once you introduce paid subscriptions, Substack takes a 10% cut of your earnings. This can add up significantly over time.

• Limited customization: Branding options are minimal, making it difficult to create a distinct visual identity for your newsletter.

• Basic analytics: Substack provides essential metrics, but more advanced analytics and insights are lacking.

• SEO struggles: The inability to control technical SEO aspects can make it harder to rank your newsletter content on search engines.

Beehiiv: The Powerhouse for Growth and Monetization

Beehiiv positions itself as a more comprehensive solution for those serious about building a sustainable newsletter business. Key benefits include:

• Own your audience: With beehiiv, you have complete ownership of your subscriber data. This allows for portability and flexibility if you ever decide to switch platforms.

• Flexible monetization: Beehiiv offers both paid subscriptions and ad revenue models. Better yet, you keep 100% of your subscription earnings.

• Website integration: Beehiiv seamlessly turns your newsletter content into a website/blog, boosting your SEO and providing a centralized hub for your readers.

• Advanced analytics: Dive into detailed data about subscriber behavior, engagement, and growth metrics to make informed decisions

• Customization and branding: Create a unique aesthetic that reflects your brand and stands out in crowded inboxes.

Potential Beehiiv Considerations

Beehiiv's robust set of features does come with a few things to keep in mind:

• Steeper learning curve: There is slightly more involved in setting up your beehiiv publication due to the additional options.

• Modest pricing: While offering a free plan for up to 2,500 subscribers, beehiiv's paid plans start at $49 per month. Consider this an investment, especially if you're serious about newsletter monetization.

When to Choose Substack

Substack is a solid choice if these scenarios resonate with you:

• You're primarily focused on writing and aren't interested in advanced features.

• You don't plan on monetizing your newsletter, or are starting small with a limited number of paid subscribers.

• You want extreme simplicity and minimal time investment to get going.

• You value built-in network discoverability as a primary way to attract subscribers.

  

When to Choose Beehiiv

Beehiiv is ideal in these situations:

• Building a newsletter business with revenue generation is central to your plan.

• You want more control over the look, feel, and functionality of your newsletter.

• You want to own your subscriber data, leaving options open for the future.

• You prioritize SEO and want your newsletter content to rank on search engines.

• You're comfortable investing in a paid plan to get the most out of the platform.

We’re in the process of building out this Newsletter. Subscribe to add your email to our list for when we’re good to go!

Woof!